WebRTC is not working with BAS

[Fox]

@Grassman said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

https://ipbinding.online/

This website can check if WebRTC UDP based requests are blocked.
Most of all proxies can be detected this way. I am aware that there might exist proxies that can tunnel UDP.
But I do not want to use any proxy. I want to use my residential IP.
This is working without problems for any normal browser like Chrome. It is also working with CanvasInspector.
But it is not working with BAS. I do not use any proxy with BAS.

Pleas help me with this. I think it is a bug and should be fixed, but maybe I am wrong and there is a way to make it work.

[Grassman]

ok thanks this is interesting.
I tried the same and it was not working for me.
I will do more tests, though I have no idea what I should try.

[Grassman]

I have used the project GeneratePrefectCanvasRequestAutomatically.xml which can be found here:
https://community.bablosoft.com/topic/11764/perfectcanvas-tools
This script is an example how create a PerfectCanvas request with BAS.

As soon as I am using this script, the WebRTC gets blocked. It is also not working if I do only run the "Load" command without "Browser Settings" and without "Start capture". So still a bug?

If I create a new project without the PerfectCanvas request it is working:

But now in this new project I can not add the PerfectCanvas request, because the "PerfectCanvas Tools" is not available. It should be listed after the "Xpath" module.

So I can still not make it work.
Why is it not working with the project I have downloaded here from the support?
And why can I not add "PerfectCanvas" to my new project?

[Grassman]

I am a step further now.
For my new project I had to download the module which can also be found here:
https://community.bablosoft.com/topic/11764/perfectcanvas-tools
For some reason I did not have to download it when using the project from this thread.

Anyway it seems to work now. But I am not 100% sure. I will have to recreate the forum project in a new project and test it.

[Grassman]

ok after endless waste of my time to figure out what is going on here I came to the conclusion that it is just sometimes working and sometimes not.
So if the same project is working sometimes and sometimes not, then this is the definition of a bug.

[FastSpace]

@Grassman said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

ok after endless waste of my time to figure out what is going on here I came to the conclusion that it is just sometimes working and sometimes not.
So if the same project is working sometimes and sometimes not, then this is the definition of a bug.

Это не баг, сайт проверку воспринимает, если она прошла быстро (менее 4 сек). Мои прокси бывают успевают уложиться в это время или нет

Не надо искать причинно-следственные связи там где их нет.

[Grassman]

I have noticed that BAS is generally extremely slow.
So you do say me that this is the problem? I have a very fast PC but BAS is slow as hell.
So what should I do? Is there another website to check UDP-based WEBRTC requests?

[Grassman]

Maybe you should work on improving BAS instead of telling everyone that there is no problem at all........sure
At least for me BAS seems to be not what I am looking for and always telling me the problem is only on my side does not help.

[Grassman]

@FastSpace said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

@Grassman this only not work for you, not BAS.

It is still not working for me. Another UDP test with BAS:

And same test on same PC with same IP etc. but using Chrome instead of BAS:

Also ipbinding.online is again not working, no matter how often I reload the website.

So I need a way now to verify the UDP funcionality with BAS, because I think this is a bug in BAS.

[Grassman]

It seems again not working for my old projects, only for new created projects.
So it is a BAS bug 100%
Can be solved with recreating the project.

[Fox]

@Grassman said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

It seems again not working for my old projects, only for new created projects.
So it is a BAS bug 100%
Can be solved with recreating the project.

You can update all project actions automatically. If the problem does not go away from the old project, but the problem does not recur in the new project, then your old project has obsolete modules. You can close BAS, open the project file in a text editor and search for the tag "<Modules/>"

[Grassman]

I am still having this issue.
Now I am using socks5 proxies with UDP support.
www.ipbinding.online is only working with BAS 28.1.2
The 100% same script will not work with BAS 28.8.1
I think it is not a performance issue, because both versions are fast when using socks5 proxy (instead of Home-IP)

Can anyone confirm?

[Grassman]

I still think it is a critical bug in BAS.

ipbinding.online is working in BAS instandly without proxy.
Using a fast proxy with UDP support in BAS is not working.

When ipbinding.online can detect "WebRTC ist blocked at network level" then everyone can.
It is a strong indicator that you are using a proxy.

But it seems noone from BAS cares about it.

[genericname1]

@Grassman we care but not known if owner will address

[Grassman]

All I heard was the problem is the website, but i doubt it.

[telim2]

i hope they get most of this issues fixed.

[FastSpace]

@Grassman проблема в твоих прокси, они говно.

[usertrue]

@FastSpace said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

@Grassman проблема в твоих прокси, они говно.

7 бед один ответ xD

[FastSpace]

@usertrue said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

@FastSpace said in WebRTC is not working with BAS:

@Grassman проблема в твоих прокси, они говно.

7 бед один ответ xD

На дворе 2025 год, куча всяких разных ИИ. Все тебе расскажут и помогут
Но нет, ведь же находиться люди кто приходит на помойку в шоп с прокси и пытается в этой помойке найти вкусный торт с вишенкой найти хорошие прокси. Все ищет, ищет и не находит. Так не ходи на помойку господи.

[Grassman]

You think there are no UDP proxies available?
I do not think so.
iproyal.com has UDP support and you can test it for example here: https://abrahamjuliot.github.io/creepjs/
But UDP support does not automatically mean BAS can handle WebRTC with UDP.
ipbinding.online is still not working with BAS.
I have tried different UDP proxy seller.
It is arrogant to say the whole world is selling UDP proxies that are not working and BAS is the only thing working correctly.
If this is true then proof it.